Follow Up, The Nurse, the DJ’s and the Royal Family.

Seal of Pima County, Arizona

Seal of Pima County, Arizona (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The nurse who killed herself after the prank phone call in England was buried.  Thank you to my library, the Pima County Public Library in answering my query about whether her suicide was cultural.  Judge for yourselves.


Dear Mr. Charton,
Thank you for your question to Ask A Librarian about the tragic death of the nurse in Australia after she was duped by radio talk show hosts to forward a call to a royal couple staying in her hospital.
You question is a tricky one in that we have, even after all this time, little solid information about the life and habits of the nurse, Jacintha Saldanha.  Her body was however returned to India for burial in a Catholic cemetery after a Catholic church service. In as much as her faith was part of her personal culture, the Catholic Church strongly discourages suicide.
In as much as Ms. Saldanha remained connected to her Indian culture, and again we have no knowledge of how deep this connection may have run, she may have been aware of two trends in India–one ancient and one modern that do unfortunately turn to suicide as an “out” in shameful or embarrassing or highly emotional situations.
In the modern case, India is witnessing a rising rate of suicide among male farmers due to financial ruin and the shame that follows from this for a man expected to support his family. Here is a news item on this development:
India as a whole faces a disturbing problem with suicide levels, more so in some provinces than others:
The ancient precedent for suicide more so for women is Sati, whereby a Hindu widow more often before the turn of the 20th century might throw herself onto the burning funeral pyre of her husband to leave earthly life along with him. An article explaining this practice can be read here:   This is explained as a practice more of the north rather than the southwest provinces, such as Karnataka, from which Ms. Saldanha hailed.
We may never really know what motivated her to commit suicide unless the notes she left behind are published. One can presume that in them she explains to some extent her thinking and reasons for taking the action she does. There are other than the above, no  overarching social, personal, or cultural reasons we can ascertain for her taking the drastic decision she did.

Thank you for using our Ask a Librarian service.

Joel D. Valdez Main Library
Pima County Public Library



About tucsonmike

I am originally from Brooklyn, New York and now live in Tucson, Arizona. I have discovered a passion for writing. I have five books out now, with a sixth on the way. Take a look @ my book list: The Search for Livingstone An Affair of the Heart The Search for Otzi Griffith Justice in Space. Moriarty The Life and Times of a Criminal Genius Available now on Smashwords - Amazon and Barnes and Noble As to not bore my public with just "Buy my book," I am also interested in baseball, the outdoors, art, architecture, technology, the human mind and DNA. I learned Ashkenazi Jews, of which I am one, have to lowest rate of Alzheimer's in the world. Therefore, I treat my brain as a muscle needing a workout. I enjoy good food, flirtation, beautiful women (I am happily married for thirty years), so just flirting ;) I was considered autistic when I was young, trying to figure out if I have a mild form of Aspergers and learning from that. That is for future posts. You can also see I love history. Enjoy my sarcastic silly look at the world, and making History more interesting than a textbook.
This entry was posted in Arizona, Tucson, Tucson Festival of Books, United Kingdom and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s